Prediction markets collide with national security

Overview

Prediction markets have existed in legal limbo since 2003, when U.S. senators killed a Pentagon program that would have let people bet on terrorist attacks. Now the feared scenario has arrived: an Israeli reservist and civilian face prosecution for using classified military intelligence to profit $150,000 on Polymarket, placing bets on the June 2025 Israel-Iran war with suspicious accuracy. It is the first known prosecution anywhere for using military secrets to trade on a prediction market.

The case caps a string of suspicious trades that have plagued Polymarket: a $400,000 windfall from bets placed hours before the U.S. captured Venezuelan leader Nicolás Maduro, $90,000 in profits from correctly predicting the Nobel Peace Prize winner, and near-perfect calls on Google search rankings. With Polymarket now valued near $10 billion and handling over $12 billion in trades annually, lawmakers are racing to decide whether prediction markets are valuable price-discovery tools or national security liabilities that incentivize insiders to monetize secrets.

Play on this story Voices Debate Predict

Key Indicators

$150,000

Israeli Defendants' Alleged Profits

Amount the reservist and civilian allegedly made betting on Israel-Iran military operations with classified intelligence

$12B+

Annual Trade Volume

Combined 2025 trading volume on Polymarket and Kalshi, the two dominant prediction market platforms

Major Insider Trading Incidents

High-profile cases of suspected insider trading on Polymarket since June 2025, including military, political, and corporate events

1st

Prosecution Using Military Secrets

The Israeli indictment marks the first known criminal case for using classified military information on a prediction market

Interactive

Exploring all sides of a story is often best achieved with Play.

Ever wondered what historical figures would say about today's headlines?

People Involved

Ritchie Torres

Championing prediction market regulation

Caroline D. Pham

Advocated for lighter prediction market regulation

Organizations Involved

Polymarket

Crypto-based prediction market platform

Faces regulatory scrutiny amid insider trading scandals

Crypto-native prediction market platform that allows users to bet on real-world events using cryptocurrency.

Shin Bet

Israeli Security Agency

Led investigation into Polymarket insider trading

Israel's internal security service responsible for counterintelligence and counterterrorism.

Kalshi

Federally regulated event-contract exchange

Operating as CFTC-registered designated contract market

Federally regulated prediction market exchange that requires full Know Your Customer and Anti-Money Laundering compliance.

Commodity Futures Trading Commission

U.S. federal regulatory agency

Drafting new prediction market rules

U.S. federal agency that regulates derivatives markets including prediction market contracts.

Timeline

IDF Confirms No Operational Damage From Leak
Statement

The Israel Defense Forces states that while the Polymarket betting scheme was 'a severe ethical failure and a clear crossing of a red line,' no operational harm resulted from the classified information leak.
February 13th, 2026
Israel Indicts Reservist and Civilian for Polymarket Scheme
Legal

Israeli authorities indict a military reservist and civilian for using classified intelligence about the June 2025 Iran strikes to profit approximately $150,000 on Polymarket. It is the first known prosecution for using military secrets on a prediction market.
February 12th, 2026
Rep. Torres Introduces Insider Trading Bill
Legislative

Rep. Ritchie Torres introduces the Public Integrity in Financial Prediction Markets Act, which would ban federal officials from trading prediction contracts when they have access to material nonpublic information.
January 5th, 2026
Trader Nets $400,000 on Maduro Capture Bet
Market Activity

An anonymous Polymarket user turns a $32,000 bet into a $400,000 profit after correctly predicting the U.S. would remove Venezuelan leader Nicolás Maduro, with the wager placed hours before the operation became public.
January 3rd, 2026
Suspicious Bets Correctly Predict Nobel Peace Prize Winner
Market Activity

Polymarket traders place hundreds of thousands of dollars on Venezuelan opposition leader María Corina Machado hours before she is announced as the 2025 Nobel Peace Prize winner, earning roughly $90,000 in profits. Norway opens an espionage investigation.
October 9th, 2025
CFTC Clears Polymarket for Limited U.S. Return
Regulatory

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission issues a no-action letter allowing Polymarket to resume limited U.S. operations through a registered intermediary, ending the platform's years-long exile from American markets.
September 1st, 2025
Israel Launches 'Rising Lion' Strike on Iran
Military

Israel begins 12-day war with Iran, striking nuclear facilities and military targets across 27 provinces. The conflict claims 28 Israeli lives and eliminates 30 senior Iranian commanders before a U.S.-brokered ceasefire on June 24.
June 13th, 2025
Polymarket Account 'ricosuave666' Begins Winning Streak
Market Activity

A Polymarket trader using the handle ricosuave666 places multiple bets on Israeli military operations in Iran with suspicious accuracy, ultimately earning over $150,000 with no losing positions on Israel-related markets.
June 13th, 2025
Kalshi Wins Court Battle Over Political Contracts
Legal

Federal court rules Kalshi can offer political event contracts, rejecting CFTC efforts to block them. The decision opens the door for regulated prediction markets on elections and government actions.
October 1st, 2024
Senators Kill Pentagon 'Terrorism Futures' Market
Regulatory

U.S. Senators Byron Dorgan and Ron Wyden condemn DARPA's Policy Analysis Market as a terrorism and assassination betting scheme. The program is shut down within days, setting a two-decade precedent against prediction markets tied to violence.
July 28th, 2003

Scenarios

Predict which scenario wins. Contrarian picks score more — points lock in when the scenario resolves.

Predictions leaderboard

Congress Passes Insider Trading Restrictions

Torres's bill gains bipartisan momentum following the Israeli prosecution and continued insider trading scandals. Federal officials become prohibited from trading on prediction markets tied to government decisions, but the platforms themselves remain legal. This creates a two-tier system where insiders face penalties while the underlying market activity continues.

Discussed by: Rep. Ritchie Torres, Democratic House members, good-government advocates

Consensus —

Prediction Markets Face War and Violence Bans

The Israeli case and other incidents prompt regulators or Congress to extend Kalshi's existing ban on war, terrorism, and assassination contracts to all prediction market platforms. Polymarket either complies by delisting geopolitical markets or faces enforcement action. The industry pivots toward less sensitive event categories.

Discussed by: Council on Foreign Relations analysts, national security experts, Democratic lawmakers

Consensus —

Industry Self-Regulates to Avoid Restrictions

Facing legislative threats, Polymarket and competitors voluntarily implement Know Your Customer requirements and surveillance systems to detect suspicious trading patterns. The CFTC accepts industry self-regulation as sufficient, and Congress does not act. Insider trading continues but becomes harder to execute at scale.

Discussed by: Polymarket leadership, industry trade groups, crypto-friendly regulators

Consensus —

Markets Continue Operating With Minimal Oversight

The pro-prediction-market Trump administration blocks Torres's bill and encourages CFTC deregulation. Polymarket expands U.S. operations. Occasional prosecutions occur in foreign jurisdictions, but U.S. traders face few constraints. The industry reaches mainstream adoption with persistent insider trading as an accepted cost.

Discussed by: Prediction market advocates, crypto libertarians, Trump administration officials

Consensus —

Historical Context

DARPA Policy Analysis Market (2003)

July-August 2003

What Happened

The Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency developed a prediction market called the Policy Analysis Market that would have allowed trading on political, economic, and military events in the Middle East. On July 28, 2003, Senators Byron Dorgan and Ron Wyden held a press conference denouncing it as a 'terrorism futures market' that would let people profit from assassinations and attacks.

Outcome

Short Term

The program was canceled within 48 hours. DARPA Information Awareness Office director John Poindexter resigned days later.

Long Term

The controversy established a 20-year precedent that prediction markets on violence were politically toxic, shaping regulatory attitudes toward the industry until the 2024-2025 deregulation wave.

Why It's Relevant Today

The Israeli case represents exactly what senators feared in 2003: someone with advance knowledge of military operations using that information for financial gain on a prediction market. The question is whether this prosecution will trigger the same regulatory backlash.

Martha Stewart ImClone Insider Trading (2001-2004)

December 2001 - March 2004

What Happened

Lifestyle mogul Martha Stewart sold 3,928 shares of ImClone Systems stock on December 27, 2001, one day before the FDA announced it would not review the company's cancer drug application. She avoided approximately $45,000 in losses. Federal prosecutors charged her with securities fraud, obstruction of justice, and conspiracy.

Outcome

Short Term

Stewart was convicted in March 2004 and served five months in federal prison plus five months of home confinement.

Long Term

The case became the defining example of celebrity insider trading prosecution, demonstrating that even relatively small profits ($45,000) could result in criminal conviction when material nonpublic information was involved.

Why It's Relevant Today

The Israeli defendants allegedly made $150,000—more than three times Stewart's avoided losses—using classified military intelligence. The comparison illustrates how prediction markets have created new avenues for insider trading that existing securities law was not designed to address.

Billy Walters Sports Betting Empire (1980s-2017)

1980s - 2017

What Happened

Professional gambler Billy Walters built a sports betting operation that consistently beat Las Vegas casinos, employing sophisticated analytics and cultivating insider sources. In 2017, he was convicted of insider trading after using tips from Dean Foods chairman Tom Davis to make $43 million in stock profits.

Outcome

Short Term

Walters was sentenced to five years in federal prison, serving three years before receiving a presidential pardon from Donald Trump in 2020.

Long Term

The case demonstrated how professional bettors operate networks to gain informational advantages, and how the line between legal information gathering and illegal insider trading can blur in betting contexts.

Why It's Relevant Today

The 'ricosuave666' Polymarket account showed the same pattern as Walters's operation: consistent winning on a narrow category of bets suggesting systematic informational advantage rather than luck. Prediction markets create similar incentives for sophisticated actors to cultivate insider sources.