Neuron doctrine debate, Golgi vs. Cajal (1906)
Camillo Golgi and Santiago Ramón y Cajal shared the 1906 Nobel Prize yet disagreed on the most basic question of brain structure: whether neurons were physically continuous or separate cells. Cajal's drawings of discrete neurons, using Golgi's own staining method, eventually won.
Cajal's neuron doctrine became the foundation of modern neuroscience.
Textbook illustrations based on Cajal's drawings shaped how generations of students visualized the brain.
The pearled axon finding challenges the same textbook lineage, suggesting Cajal's smooth-tube drawings, however elegant, omitted a structural feature visible only with modern imaging.
