Pull to refresh
Logo
What Changed
Following Why Sign Up
NYPD won't enforce NYC bus fares while MTA's enforcement team is suspended

NYPD won't enforce NYC bus fares while MTA's enforcement team is suspended

Rule Changes New York, NY local

The $3 bus fare goes largely unenforced as the MTA's EAGLE investigation drags past its early-November target and Mayor Mamdani pushes free buses

2 days ago: MTA reviews EAGLE training; 250 agents reassigned

Overview

Updated Yesterday

The MTA suspended its 350-member EAGLE fare enforcement team on Oct. 28 after two confrontations with riders were caught on video. The NYPD says it will not step in, so the $3 bus fare is largely unenforced. About 250 EAGLE members have been reassigned to other duties while the agency investigates.

MTA data shows 48.2% of bus riders skip the fare, up from 44% in 2025. The internal investigation, expected to finish in early November, is still running. Mayor Zohran Mamdani's office cites the controversy as evidence for his free-bus plan, which still has no funding source.

Why it matters

The MTA loses $300 million a year to unpaid bus fares; the enforcement vacuum may push the city toward making buses free.

Last Monday's email for New York, NY

Sent Nov 9. It carried:

Get next Monday's: one short email a week. Free. Unsubscribe in one click.

Questions about this story

Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

Key Indicators

$300M+
Annual MTA loss to unpaid bus fares
The MTA's estimate. A Citizens Budget Commission estimate put 2024 losses from bus fare-skipping at $568 million.
48.2%
Bus riders who skip the fare
MTA data reported Nov. 9, up from 44% in 2025.
350
EAGLE agents
The fare enforcement unit is suspended; about 250 members have been reassigned to other duties.
$3
NYC bus fare
The fare currently in effect for city buses.

Voices

Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.

Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.

Log in Sign Up

People Involved

Janno Lieber
Janno Lieber
Chair and CEO, Metropolitan Transportation Authority
Suspended the EAGLE team on Oct. 22 pending investigation; says the team is needed to correct rider behavior and is weighing body cameras
 Zohran Kwame Mamdani
Zohran Kwame Mamdani
Mayor of New York City
Pushing free-bus proposal; cites EAGLE controversy as evidence
KT
Kyle Taylor
Brooklyn high school aide
Plans to sue MTA over alleged assault by EAGLE agents
LD
Lisa Daglian
Executive director, Permanent Citizens Advisory Committee to the MTA
Calls the pause a 'hiccup' but warns of service reductions
 Demetrius Crichlow
Demetrius Crichlow
President, NYC Transit
Leading the EAGLE review; says physical contact with riders is not agency policy
 Andrew Albert
Andrew Albert
Member, MTA Board
Urging automatic fare-detection technology on buses

Organizations Involved

Metropolitan Transportation Authority
Metropolitan Transportation Authority
Transit agency
Investigating the EAGLE team; about 250 agents reassigned while the review continues

The MTA operates New York City's buses, subways, and commuter rails.
New York City Police Department
New York City Police Department
Police department
Refuses to enforce bus fares

The NYPD is New York City's main law enforcement agency.
EA
EAGLE team
Transit fare enforcement unit
Suspended indefinitely; about 250 members reassigned to other duties as of Nov. 9

The MTA's 350-person fare enforcement unit, suspended after caught-on-camera confrontations.
PC
Permanent Citizens Advisory Committee to the MTA
Rider watchdog group
Calls pause a 'hiccup'

A rider advisory group that works with the MTA on transit policy.

Timeline

August 2026 November 2026

12 events Latest: 2 days ago Showing 8 of 12
Tap a bar to jump to that date

  1. MTA reviews EAGLE training; 250 agents reassigned

    Latest Policy Development

    NYC Transit President Demetrius Crichlow told a committee meeting that physical contact with riders is not agency policy and about 250 EAGLE members are doing video retrieval, graffiti investigations and yard inspections. Board member Andrew Albert urged automatic fare-detection technology.

  2. Bus fare evasion hits 48.2%, MTA data shows

    Data

    Official MTA figures reported Nov. 9 put bus fare evasion at 48.2%, up from 44% in 2025. Since May the EAGLE team had used handheld devices to verify payment on moving buses.

  3. EAGLE suspension continues as investigation runs

    Investigation

    The Brooklyn College Vanguard reports the EAGLE team remains suspended indefinitely while the MTA's Special Investigations and Review unit completes its review.

  4. NYPD says it won't enforce bus fares

    Statement

    Gothamist reports the NYPD has no plans to assist with EAGLE enforcement, leaving the fare unenforced.

  5. MTA weighs body cameras for EAGLE team

    Policy Development

    Agency considers equipping agents with body cameras and adding a clearer complaint process.

  6. MTA says probe will finish the week of Nov. 2

    Investigation

    NYC Transit President Demetrius Crichlow said the probe into both incidents should finish mid to late next week. A separate review of EAGLE operations is also underway.

  7. MTA considers checking EAGLE hires' past police records

    Policy Development

    Board member David Jones asked whether EAGLE hires' prior law-enforcement records are reviewed. Crichlow said the MTA is exploring using them and is consulting HR and legal.

  8. City Council Progressive Caucus calls for permanent halt

    Political Response

    The caucus urged the MTA to permanently stop using EAGLE teams for bus fare enforcement after the confrontations.

  9. MTA suspends EAGLE fare enforcement team

    Policy Change

    Chair Janno Lieber announced the suspension at a news conference in Ozone Park, Queens, pending an investigation into the confrontations.

  10. Alleged assault on Brooklyn high school aide

    Incident

    EAGLE agents allegedly pin Kyle Taylor against a bus shelter and shove him to the ground in Brownsville.

  11. Staten Island lawmakers demand a fare enforcement plan

    Political Response

    Elected officials called on the MTA to set out a clear plan for fare evasion after the suspension.

  12. EAGLE officer tackles passenger in the Bronx

    Incident

    Video shows an EAGLE officer tackling a man getting off a Bx39 bus; three more officers restrain him.

Scenarios

1

EAGLE team returns with body cameras and new rules

Likely Resolves by Q2 2027

Discussed by: MTA officials, Gothamist reporting

After the investigation, the MTA reinstates its 350 agents with body cameras, a clearer complaint process, and retraining. Lieber has said he expects the team to come back as 'an even better operation.' The key unknown is how long the probe takes and whether the NYPD changes its refusal.

2

Mamdani wins free bus funding in city budget

Possible Resolves by Q2 2027

Discussed by: Mayor's office, transit advocates

Mayor Mamdani proposes a funding mechanism to replace bus fare revenue and makes free buses part of the city budget. He has not yet said where the money would come from. The NYPD refusal and EAGLE pause strengthen his case that fare enforcement is not worth the cost.

3

Fare evasion spikes while enforcement stays frozen

Possible Resolves by Q1 2027

Discussed by: MTA fare data, rider advocates

With no one checking fares, the share of non-paying bus riders climbs above the current half, and the MTA's revenue losses grow. The agency then faces pressure to either restore enforcement or accept deeper budget cuts. The risk is that once skipping the fare becomes the norm, it is hard to reverse.

4

MTA probe finds misconduct and disciplines EAGLE agents

Possible Resolves by End of 2026

Discussed by: MTA Chair Janno Lieber, NYC Transit President Demetrius Crichlow

Lieber said the investigation could lead to discipline under the agency's union contract. Crichlow said the findings will go to the chair and some details to the board. How much the MTA will make public is unclear.

Historical Context

3 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.

1990s

Broken Windows fare enforcement (1990s)

In the mid-1990s, Police Commissioner William Bratton and Mayor Rudy Giuliani made subway fare evasion a top enforcement priority under Broken Windows policing. Officers arrested and fined thousands of turnstile jumpers, arguing that cracking down on small offenses deterred bigger crime.

Then

Crime fell sharply in the city, and the approach was widely credited, though criminologists still debate how large a role it played.

Now

Fare enforcement became a permanent part of transit policing and set the model for the EAGLE team's aggressive tactics.

Why this matters now

The EAGLE team is a direct descendant of that 1990s approach. The current backlash shows how much the politics of fare enforcement have flipped.

2020-2021

COVID-19 transit enforcement pullback (2020-2021)

When the pandemic emptied New York's subways in 2020, ridership collapsed and the NYPD largely stopped enforcing fares. Turnstile jumping and unpaid bus fares became common.

Then

The MTA lost billions in fare revenue and never fully recovered ridership.

Now

Fare evasion became normalized, and the agency has struggled to reverse the habit ever since.

Why this matters now

It is a preview of what an enforcement vacuum looks like at scale: once skipping the fare becomes the norm, it is hard to claw back.

December 2019

Kansas City becomes first major U.S. city with free buses (2019)

Kansas City, Missouri became the first major U.S. city to eliminate fares on all its buses. The city council approved it with support from transit riders and business groups.

Then

Ridership rose, and the city used federal pandemic aid to keep the policy going.

Now

It became a test case for free transit, though other cities have been slow to follow.

Why this matters now

Mamdani's free-bus proposal is the largest version yet of this model, and the enforcement pause gives him a window to argue for it.

Sources

(8)
+2
Gothamist amNewYork SILive DNYUZ PIX11 SondeAR The Brooklyn College Vanguard amNewYork