The end of the H-1B lottery

Overview

On December 29, 2025, the Department of Homeland Security published its final rule replacing the H-1B lottery with wage-weighted selection. It takes effect February 27, 2026.

Under the new system, a software engineer offered $150,000 (Level IV) gets four entries; one offered $65,000 (Level I) gets one—an 8.5% chance versus 25% under the prior system. The change targets fraud. In FY 2024, 758,994 registrations competed for 85,000 slots; 408,891 were duplicates, up 140% year-over-year.

Shell companies flooded the system. Disney laid off American IT staff and made them train H-1B replacements paid 40% less. On December 24, a federal judge upheld the $100,000 H-1B fee Trump imposed in September, rejecting a U.S. Chamber of Commerce lawsuit.

U.S. consulates in India began canceling thousands of H-1B visa appointments in December, pushing them to mid-2026 due to new mandatory social media screening. India's Nasscom called for delaying wage-weighting until FY 2028, warning it will crush entry-level hiring and favor deep-pocketed Big Tech over startups and research institutions. Twenty states sued Trump over the $100K fee; Vice President JD Vance defended the restrictions as 'true Christian politics,' saying companies shouldn't 'bypass American labor for cheaper options in the third world.'

The battle spans courtrooms, consulates, and Congress: Will wage-weighting stop fraud, or just hand visas to Google while crushing entry-level hiring?

Play on this story Voices Debate Who Said What? Predict

Key Indicators

758,994

FY 2024 H-1B Registrations

Applications for 85,000 available slots—a 60% jump from 474,421 the prior year

408,891

Duplicate Registrations

Multiple employers filed for same beneficiaries in FY 2024—54% of all submissions

Level IV Wage Advantage

Highest-paid workers get quadruple entries versus lowest wage tier under new system

70-75%

Indian National Share

Percentage of H-1B holders from India; ~300,000 Indians work in US on these visas

Interactive

Exploring all sides of a story is often best achieved with Play.

Ever wondered what historical figures would say about today's headlines?

People Involved

Alejandro N. Mayorkas

Finalized wage-weighted H-1B rule December 2025

Chuck Grassley

Co-sponsor of H-1B reform bills since 2007

Elon Musk

Defending H-1B visas amid MAGA backlash, December 2024-January 2025

Donald Trump

Flip-flopped on H-1B policy; now supports program

J.D. Vance

Defending H-1B restrictions as pro-American worker policy, December 2025

Beryl A. Howell

Ruled Trump's $100,000 H-1B fee lawful, December 24, 2025

Rob Bonta

Leading 20-state lawsuit against $100,000 H-1B fee

Organizations Involved

U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS)

Federal Agency

Administering H-1B program; enforcing fraud crackdown

USCIS runs the H-1B cap lottery and processes petitions for the 85,000 annual visas.

Cognizant Technology Solutions

IT Services and Consulting Corporation

Major H-1B user; sued in Disney case

Global IT services company that files thousands of H-1B petitions annually, often for lower-wage positions.

HCL Technologies

IT Outsourcing Firm

Major H-1B user; sued in Disney case

Indian multinational IT services firm and heavy H-1B petitioner, often criticized for wage suppression.

The Walt Disney Company

Media and entertainment conglomerate

Faced backlash and lawsuit over 2015 H-1B layoffs

Used H-1B outsourcing to replace American IT workers in 2015, sparking national controversy.

National Association of Software and Service Companies (Nasscom)

Industry Trade Association

Opposing wage-weighted H-1B rule; calling for delay until FY 2028

India's premier IT industry association representing over 3,000 companies employing 5.4 million workers.

U.S. Chamber of Commerce

Business Advocacy Organization

Lost lawsuit challenging $100,000 H-1B fee, December 24, 2025

Largest U.S. business lobbying group; filed October 2025 lawsuit against Trump's $100K H-1B fee.

Timeline

New System Takes Effect
Implementation

Wage-weighted selection begins for FY 2027 H-1B cap season.
February 27th, 2026
Rule Published in Federal Register
Regulation

Wage-weighted selection rule formally published.
December 29th, 2025
Judge Upholds $100,000 H-1B Fee
Legal

U.S. District Judge Beryl Howell rejects U.S. Chamber of Commerce lawsuit, ruling Trump's September proclamation imposing $100K fee falls within executive authority under Immigration and Nationality Act.
December 24th, 2025
Nasscom Calls for Delay Until FY 2028
Industry Response

India's IT industry association warns wage-weighted selection will disadvantage startups, small businesses, and entry-level STEM graduates; urges phased implementation starting FY 2028 instead of FY 2027.
December 24th, 2025
DHS Announces Wage-Weighted Selection
Regulation

Final rule replaces lottery with wage-based weighting effective Feb 2026.
December 23rd, 2025
Social Media Screening Begins at U.S. Consulates
Enforcement

U.S. Embassy in India starts mandatory online presence reviews for all H-1B and H-4 applicants, canceling thousands of December-January appointments and rescheduling to March-August 2026.
December 15th, 2025
20 States Sue Over $100,000 H-1B Fee
Legal

Coalition led by California, New York, and Massachusetts files lawsuit alleging Trump's September fee violates Administrative Procedure Act and exceeds executive authority.
December 12th, 2025
Trump Imposes $100,000 H-1B Fee
Executive

New fee targets program abuse; Indian IT stocks plunge.
September 20th, 2025
Musk-Bannon H-1B Feud
Political

MAGA coalition splits over visas; Trump sides with Musk, calls program 'great.'
December 28th, 2024
FY 2024 Registrations Hit Record
Data

758,994 registrations submitted; 54% are duplicates for same workers.
March 2024
USCIS Launches Fraud Investigations
Enforcement

Agency investigates dozens of companies for coordinated lottery gaming.
May 2023
Grassley-Durbin Bill Reintroduced
Legislation

H-1B and L-1 Visa Reform Act filed again; dies in committee.
March 28th, 2023
Trump Bans New H-1B Visas
Executive

Temporary ban issued, later struck down by federal courts.
June 2020
Electronic Registration Launches
Policy

USCIS introduces online H-1B lottery registration; fraud explodes.
March 1st, 2020
Trump's 'Buy American, Hire American'
Executive

Executive order directs agencies to review H-1B program for abuse.
April 18th, 2017
Workers Sue Disney
Legal

Laid-off employees file federal lawsuit alleging illegal replacement with H-1Bs.
January 2016
New York Times Exposé
Media

Disney H-1B scandal breaks nationally, triggering congressional scrutiny.
June 2015
Disney Layoffs Take Effect
Corporate

Workers laid off after training H-1B replacements paid 40% less.
January 30th, 2015
Disney Notifies IT Workers of Layoffs
Corporate

250 Disney IT staff told they'll be replaced by H-1B workers from outsourcing firms.
October 2014
First Grassley-Durbin Reform Bill
Legislation

Senators introduce H-1B fraud prevention bill; fails to pass.
2007
Cap Set at 85,000
Legislation

H-1B Visa Reform Act sets 65,000 regular cap plus 20,000 for US master's degrees.
2004
H-1B Program Created
Legislation

Immigration Act of 1990 establishes H-1B visa for specialty occupations.
1990

Scenarios

Predict which scenario wins. Contrarian picks score more — points lock in when the scenario resolves.

Predictions leaderboard

Big Tech Dominates, Startups Shut Out

Google, Meta, and Amazon hoover up visas by offering Level IV salaries ($150K+) that small companies can't match. Startups needing niche AI or cryptography talent get frozen out even when offering competitive equity packages, because cash wage determines lottery weight. Indian IT outsourcers pivot to 'staff augmentation' at higher rates, passing costs to clients. Concentration accelerates: top 50 employers capture 60% of all H-1Bs versus 40% pre-reform. Congress holds hearings on unintended consequences but takes no action. Venture capitalists lobby for carve-outs; none pass.

Discussed by: Startup founders, immigration attorneys, Federal Register public comments

Consensus —

Fraud Migrates to Wage Inflation

Shell companies and body shops game the new system by listing inflated Level IV wages on registrations, then paying Level I salaries after approval via side agreements or mandatory 'training fee' kickbacks. USCIS scrambles to audit actual compensation post-selection but lacks resources to verify 85,000 petitions annually. Whistleblowers report rampant wage fraud; enforcement lags years behind. Congress debates mandatory wage verification and site inspections. Meanwhile, legitimate employers bear audit burden while bad actors exploit gaps. By 2028, wage fraud eclipses the old lottery manipulation.

Discussed by: Immigration enforcement officials, fraud investigators, policy analysts

Consensus —

Reform Works, Fraud Collapses

Wage-weighting kills the incentive for duplicate registrations: no point filing 10 entries for a Level I worker when one Level IV worker has quadruple the odds. FY 2027 registrations drop 40% to 450,000; duplicates fall to under 5%. Outsourcing firms either raise wages genuinely or exit the H-1B market, shifting to L-1 visas and nearshoring in Mexico. Median H-1B salary climbs from $95,000 to $125,000. Universities and research labs win more visas for PhD scientists. Displacement complaints decrease. Critics still argue the cap should rise or the program should end, but consensus forms: wage-weighting fixed the lottery's worst abuses.

Discussed by: DHS officials, immigration reform advocates, mainstream immigration attorneys

Consensus —

Congressional Overhaul Replaces Executive Fix

Wage-weighting proves a stopgap. In 2026, Republicans control Congress and pass comprehensive H-1B reform increasing the cap to 110,000 but mandating Level III minimum wages, site audits, and criminal penalties for fraud. Democrats extract green card pathways for STEM PhD graduates in exchange. The bill sunsets DHS's wage-weighted rule, replacing it with statutory requirements. Indian IT firms lobby fiercely; tech giants back the compromise. The law passes with 65 Senate votes. By 2027, the H-1B program looks unrecognizable: higher wages, more enforcement, clearer pathways to permanence.

Discussed by: Senate immigration hawks, tech industry lobbyists, bipartisan reform groups

Consensus —

Historical Context

Canada's Points System Shift (2015)

1967-2015

What Happened

Canada pioneered points-based immigration in 1967, awarding visas based on education, language, age, and skills without employer sponsorship. For decades, immigrants arrived without job offers, leading to credential mismatches—engineers driving taxis. In 2015, Canada introduced Express Entry, a hybrid model: candidates still need points, but employers select from a pre-approved pool, blending supply-driven points with demand-driven hiring.

Outcome

Short Term

Applications spiked; processing times dropped from years to months.

Long Term

Immigrant employment outcomes improved significantly as employer involvement ensured job market fit.

Why It's Relevant Today

The US H-1B wage-weighted system mirrors Canada's evolution: moving from pure randomness toward valuing market signals—here, wages as a proxy for skill and demand—without abandoning employer sponsorship entirely.

Australia's 457 Visa Abuse and Reform (2017)

1996-2018

What Happened

Australia's Temporary Skill Shortage (subclass 457) visa allowed employers to sponsor foreign workers. By 2017, widespread abuse emerged: employers sponsoring workers for fake jobs, paying below-market wages, or using 457s to suppress Australian salaries. In April 2017, Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull abolished the 457 visa, replacing it with the Temporary Skill Shortage (TSS) visa with stricter wage floors, mandatory labor market testing, and occupation lists tied to genuine shortages.

Outcome

Short Term

Visa grants dropped 20%; businesses protested disruption.

Long Term

Wage protections strengthened; public trust in skilled migration partially restored.

Why It's Relevant Today

Like the 457 visa, the H-1B lottery faced exploitation by employers seeking cheap labor rather than scarce talent. The US wage-weighted rule parallels Australia's wage floor approach: using compensation as a gatekeeper to prioritize genuine skill needs over cost arbitrage.

Disney's H-1B Layoffs (2015)

2014-2015

What Happened

In October 2014, Walt Disney World notified 250 IT workers they'd be laid off and replaced by H-1B workers from Cognizant and HCL—outsourcing firms paying $61,000 versus Disney's $100,000 salaries. Workers spent 90 days training their replacements or lost severance. The scandal broke nationally in June 2015 via the New York Times, sparking lawsuits alleging illegal displacement and congressional hearings on program abuse.

Outcome

Short Term

Disney reversed 35 layoffs; lawsuits filed but largely dismissed on standing grounds.

Long Term

The case became a rallying cry for H-1B critics, illustrating wage suppression and the gap between statutory intent (fill labor shortages) and corporate practice (cut costs).

Why It's Relevant Today

The Disney case epitomizes the problem DHS's wage-weighted rule aims to solve: employers using H-1Bs not for specialized talent but for cheaper labor. By prioritizing higher wages, the new system theoretically blocks the cost-cutting outsourcing model that enabled Disney's layoffs.