Pull to refresh
Logo
What Changed
Following Why Sign Up
Fat Peach Bakery opens second location in Hyde Park

Fat Peach Bakery opens second location in Hyde Park

Money Moves Chicago, IL local

Bridgeport bakery opens on 53rd Street a day late, after a delivery near-miss ruined its first pastry batch

5 days ago: Hyde Park soft opening begins

Overview

Updated 4 days ago

Fat Peach opened its second shop Friday at 1613 E. 53rd St. in Hyde Park, a day after the planned debut. A driver swerved into co-owner David Castillo's lane during a Thursday delivery; he was unhurt, but the pastries for opening day were ruined.

For the first week the shop is open 8 a.m. to 3 p.m. Friday through Sunday, with regular hours still to be set. The owners plan a full launch next week without a ribbon-cutting. Fat Peach opened in Bridgeport in August 2024 and is nominated for a Jean Banchet Award for its pastry program.

Why it matters

A two-person Bridgeport bakery built on sold-out weekends is testing whether its pastries draw the same crowds on 53rd Street.

Last Monday's email for Chicago, IL

Sent Nov 9. It carried:

Get next Monday's: one short email a week. Free. Unsubscribe in one click.

Questions about this story

Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

Key Indicators

2
Fat Peach locations after Hyde Park opening
Bridgeport original opened Aug. 31, 2024; Hyde Park opened Nov. 6, 2026.
2024
Bridgeport opening year
Original Fat Peach opened in the former Bridgeport Bakery space.
8–3
First-week Hyde Park hours
Friday through Sunday, 8 a.m. to 3 p.m.; regular hours to be determined.
Nominee
Jean Banchet Award, Pastry Program of the Year
Block Club reported the nomination in its Nov. 6 story on the Hyde Park opening.

Voices

Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.

Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.

Log in Sign Up

People Involved

KB
Kerrie Breuer
Co-owner and cake decorator, Fat Peach Bakery
Operating Fat Peach's Bridgeport and Hyde Park locations
 David Castillo
David Castillo
Co-owner and chef, Fat Peach Bakery
Operating Fat Peach's Bridgeport and Hyde Park locations

Organizations Involved

Fat Peach Bakery
Fat Peach Bakery
Bakery
Opened a second shop at 1613 E. 53rd St. in Hyde Park on Nov. 6; first-week hours are 8 a.m. to 3 p.m. Friday through Sunday

Bridgeport bakery known for scratch-made pastries, now open at a second location on 53rd Street in Hyde Park.

Timeline

August 2024 November 2026

4 events Latest: 5 days ago
Tap a bar to jump to that date

  1. Hyde Park soft opening begins

    Latest Opening

    Fat Peach opened at 1613 E. 53rd St., a day after the planned debut, with first-week hours of 8 a.m. to 3 p.m. Friday through Sunday.

  2. Delivery near-miss ruins opening-day pastries

    Setback

    A driver swerved into David Castillo's lane while he was delivering to the Hyde Park shop. He was unharmed, but the pastry supply was lost and the debut slipped a day.

  3. Hyde Park expansion plans reported

    Expansion

    Newcity reports Fat Peach plans a Hyde Park location on 53rd Street.

  4. Fat Peach opens in Bridgeport

    Opening

    Fat Peach opens at 2907 S. Archer Ave. in the former Bridgeport Bakery space.

Scenarios

1

Hyde Park location matches Bridgeport demand

Possible Resolves by Feb 6, 2027

Discussed by: Local food press and the bakery's public announcements

If lines and sellouts follow Fat Peach to 53rd Street, the second shop validates the couple's scratch-made model and could support more locations. The trigger is repeat demand after the grand opening, not opening-week curiosity.

2

Hyde Park hours cut as expansion strains production

Possible Resolves by Feb 6, 2027

Discussed by: Local food press and the bakery's public schedule

A second storefront doubles daily production and staffing needs. If Fat Peach reduces Hyde Park days or hours, it would show the small operation could not replicate Bridgeport output without strain.

3

Fat Peach announces third location

Unlikely Resolves by Nov 6, 2027

Discussed by: Local food press

A successful Hyde Park launch could prompt another Chicago expansion, but the couple has not signaled plans. This scenario requires a public announcement, not speculation.

Historical Context

3 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.

January 2024

Bridgeport Bakery's final closure (2024)

Bridgeport Bakery, a neighborhood institution for more than 50 years, closed for good in January 2024 after a tumultuous ownership change. It had previously closed in 2019 after a 47-year run, reopened, and closed again in 2021 over an outstanding debt to the bakers union.

Then

The storefront sat vacant until Fat Peach took it over.

Now

Fat Peach inherited a location with built-in neighborhood recognition and a customer base accustomed to a bakery on Archer Avenue.

Why this matters now

The Hyde Park expansion is the first time Fat Peach is opening a storefront that was not a direct replacement for a closed neighborhood bakery.

August 2024

Fat Peach opens in Bridgeport (2024)

Kerrie Breuer and David Castillo opened Fat Peach on Aug. 31, 2024, in the former Bridgeport Bakery space. The shop sold scratch-made croissants and savory pastries and frequently sold out, with lines forming before opening.

Then

The bakery gained a loyal following and became a destination on Archer Avenue.

Now

The demand gave the owners a case for a second location on 53rd Street.

Why this matters now

The Hyde Park shop tests whether that following travels beyond Bridgeport.

2022

Dr. Seuss Baking Challenge win (2022)

Breuer won Amazon Studios' Dr. Seuss Baking Challenge, raising her profile as a cake decorator before she opened Fat Peach.

Then

The win gave the bakery a recognizable owner with competition credentials.

Now

It helped draw attention when Fat Peach opened in Bridgeport.

Why this matters now

Breuer's reputation is part of what Fat Peach brings to Hyde Park.

Sources

(4)
+1
Block Club Chicago Newcity Hoodline Block Club Chicago