Pull to refresh
Logo
What Changed
Following Why Sign Up
University of Utah dismisses cases against College Republicans over Kirkiversary cake post

University of Utah dismisses cases against College Republicans over Kirkiversary cake post

Rule Changes Salt Lake City, UT local

Viral photo of a student celebrating Charlie Kirk's assassination sparked doxxing, threats, and a three-day disciplinary fight.

September 17th, 2026: Cases dismissed

Overview

Updated Sep 18

A University of Utah sophomore brought a cake reading "Happy Kirkiversary" to a College Republicans table on Sept. 10 — the first anniversary of conservative activist Charlie Kirk's assassination. A club vice president photographed her, posted it to the social platform X (formerly Twitter), and the post drew 6.3 million views, triggering doxxing and death threats on both sides.

The university opened misconduct cases against the two College Republicans who shared the images, citing a "Threatening or Endangering Behavior" standard that can lead to expulsion. On Sept. 17, it dismissed both cases. The fight tests how public universities police viral political speech that turns into online targeting.

Why it matters

The case tests whether public universities can punish viral political posts without chilling speech — and who's responsible when online exposure turns into doxxing.

Last Monday's email for Salt Lake City, UT

Sent Nov 9. It carried:

Get next Monday's: one short email a week. Free. Unsubscribe in one click.

Questions about this story

Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

Key Indicators

6.3M
Views on original X post
Barnes' photo of Larsen drew 6.3 million views in three days.
~20M
Views on anonymous doxxing post
A post showing alleged LinkedIn details for Larsen and family members.
2
Disciplinary cases dismissed
Dean of Students dropped inquiries into Barnes and Beesley.
500+
Dean of Students cases this year
The office says it investigates every complaint it receives.

Voices

Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.

Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.

Log in Sign Up

People Involved

RB
Rylie Barnes
Vice president, University of Utah College Republicans
Disciplinary case dismissed Sept. 17, 2026
RB
Riley Beesley
Chairman, Utah Federation of College Republicans
Disciplinary case dismissed Sept. 17, 2026
 Sara Larsen
Sara Larsen
Sophomore, University of Utah
Apologized; received death threats after being doxxed
MM
Mason McCann
Member, College Democrats of the University and Utah
Past comments about Kirk resurfaced; says he is now a target
 Erika Kirk
Erika Kirk
Widow of Charlie Kirk
Retained legal counsel to assist Barnes and Beesley
 Charlie Kirk
Charlie Kirk
Founder, Turning Point USA (deceased)
Assassinated Sept. 10, 2025

Organizations Involved

University of Utah
University of Utah
Public research university
Dismissed disciplinary cases against Barnes and Beesley

Public university in Salt Lake City whose Dean of Students Office investigated the viral post under its "Threatening or Endangering Behavior" standard.
University of Utah College Republicans
University of Utah College Republicans
Student political organization
Faced dechartering demands; officers cleared

Campus club that was tabling for a Kirk memorial when Larsen approached with the cake; its officers posted the viral photo.
CD
College Democrats of the University and Utah
Student political organization
Called the cake 'distasteful' but condemned doxxing

Campus Democratic group that said no student deserves to be doxxed but criticized the College Republicans' post as public shaming.
Turning Point USA
Turning Point USA
Conservative nonprofit
Founded by Kirk; holds memorial events after his death

The youth organization Kirk founded; its members held the UVU memorial the cake referenced.

Timeline

September 2025 September 2026

9 events Latest: September 17th, 2026 · 2 months ago
Tap a bar to jump to that date

  1. Cases dismissed

    Latest Legal

    Dean of Students Jason Ramirez dismissed cases against Barnes and Beesley, apologizing in emails for the emotional turmoil the investigation caused.

  2. Protest and national attention

    Escalation

    Students protest seeking dechartering; Trump administration and Erika Kirk's counsel get involved; meetings canceled.

  3. Disciplinary notification

    Legal

    University notifies Barnes and Beesley of possible 'Threatening or Endangering Behavior' violations.

  4. University statement

    Statement

    University says it is reviewing circumstances and reaffirms commitment to free expression.

  5. Larsen doxxed

    Incident

    Anonymous account posts alleged LinkedIn details for Larsen and family; post draws roughly 20 million views.

  6. Beesley resurfaces McCann comments

    Escalation

    Beesley posts McCann's past Kirk comments, ending with 'MAKE HIM FAMOUS.'

  7. Larsen apologizes

    Statement

    Larsen apologizes for the cake; College Republicans publicly accept the apology.

  8. Cake incident and viral post

    Incident

    Larsen brings 'Happy Kirkiversary' cake to College Republicans booth; Barnes posts photo, drawing 6.3 million views.

  9. Charlie Kirk assassinated

    Event

    Conservative activist Charlie Kirk is shot and killed, setting the stage for the 'Kirkiversary' controversy one year later.

Scenarios

1

Anonymous doxxer faces criminal charges

Possible Resolves by Mar 17, 2027

Discussed by: Former FBI agent Greg Rogers, who told KUTV online threats are 'state and federal felonies'

Law enforcement investigates the anonymous account that posted Larsen's alleged address and family details in a post drawing nearly 20 million views. If the person is identified, Utah or federal prosecutors could file charges for doxxing and death threats.

2

University of Utah revises free speech policy

Possible Resolves by Dec 17, 2026

Discussed by: University statements on free expression; attention from the Trump administration and Erika Kirk's legal counsel

National scrutiny pushes the university to clarify when its 'Threatening or Endangering Behavior' standard applies to social media posts. The school said it 'strongly supports freedom of expression, including speech that may be controversial, offensive or deeply upsetting,' which could lead to a formal policy revision.

3

Dismissal stands; no further action

Likely Resolves by End of 2026

Discussed by: Baseline outcome given the Sept. 17 dismissal

With both disciplinary cases dropped and national attention shifting, the university returns to normal operations. The dismissal becomes the final institutional action unless law enforcement identifies the doxxer.

Historical Context

3 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.

August 2017

Unite the Right rally, Charlottesville (2017)

White nationalists gathered in Charlottesville, Virginia, for the Unite the Right rally. A counter-protester, Heather Heyer, was killed when a man drove his car into a crowd. In the aftermath, internet users crowdsourced the identities of marchers, using the phrase 'make him famous' to expose them.

Then

Several rally participants lost jobs or were publicly identified; one man was later convicted of murdering Heyer.

Now

The 'make him famous' identification tactic became a template for online doxxing campaigns.

Why this matters now

Beesley's 'MAKE HIM FAMOUS' post and the doxxing of Larsen mirror the same tactic of using viral exposure to punish political speech.

February 2017

Berkeley College Republicans / Milo Yiannopoulos (2017)

The Berkeley College Republicans invited right-wing provocateur Milo Yiannopoulos to speak. Thousands of counter-protesters shut the event down with violence, and the university canceled. The group remained at the center of free speech battles on campus.

Then

The event's cancellation sparked national debate and legal fights over campus free speech.

Now

Public universities faced pressure to protect controversial speech while ensuring safety.

Why this matters now

The U of U College Republicans, under a similar spotlight, faced dechartering demands and disciplinary action over speech.

February 1969

Tinker v. Des Moines (1969)

Three students wore black armbands to school to protest the Vietnam War and were suspended. The Supreme Court ruled 7-2 that students don't shed their First Amendment rights at the schoolhouse gate, unless speech materially disrupts the school.

Then

The suspensions were overturned; a standard was set for student speech.

Now

Tinker remains the baseline for public schools and universities disciplining student expression.

Why this matters now

The university's 'Threatening or Endangering' standard must avoid punishing protected speech, which is why the cases were dismissed.

Sources

(10)
+4
KSL Deseret News (via Yahoo News) KUTV KJZZ Daily Utah Chronicle The Salt Lake Tribune Deseret News American Greatness The Post Millennial The College Fix