Pull to refresh
Logo
What Changed
Following Why Sign Up
545 VCU Health workers face layoff as hospital switches cleaning contractor

545 VCU Health workers face layoff as hospital switches cleaning contractor

Money Moves Richmond, VA local

New contractor HHS says it will hire the full frontline team, but pay and union terms are uncertain

November 1st, 2026: HHS contract start date

Overview

Updated Sep 15

Crothall Healthcare's contract to clean VCU Health's Richmond campus was set to end Oct. 31, with 545 workers covered by the company's August layoff notice. The handoff to Texas-based HHS Environmental Services was scheduled for Nov. 1.

HHS has said it intends to hire the full frontline team. No public announcement has reported how many workers it has hired or whether it will recognize SEIU Local 32BJ, the union that negotiated $3.30-per-hour raises over three years in March 2025.

Why it matters

The transition tests whether 545 unionized cleaning workers keep the raises and protections they won in March 2025.

Last Monday's email for Richmond, VA

Sent Nov 9. It carried:

Get next Monday's: one short email a week. Free. Unsubscribe in one click.

Questions about this story

Free account needed to ask — your question is kept and asked for you right after sign-up. Answers are public.

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

Key Indicators

545
Workers in WARN notice
Crothall Healthcare employees at VCU Health affected by the contract loss.
399
Housekeeping positions
The bulk of affected roles are housekeeping and cleaning staff.
64
Days from WARN notice to layoff
August 28 filing to October 31 effective date, exceeding the 60-day WARN Act minimum.

Voices

Curated perspectives — historical figures and your fellow readers.

Sign up to generate historical perspectives on this story.

Log in Sign Up

People Involved

Lytch
Lytch
Human resources business partner, Crothall Healthcare
Signed Crothall's WARN notice; said layoffs were expected to be permanent

Organizations Involved

Crothall Healthcare
Crothall Healthcare
Healthcare support services company
Contract with VCU Health was set to end Oct. 31; WARN notice covered 545 workers

Pennsylvania-based company providing housekeeping, facilities management, and patient support services to hospitals and health systems.
HHS Environmental Services
HHS Environmental Services
Healthcare environmental services company
Selected to replace Crothall; contract start was set for Nov. 1

Texas-based environmental services provider taking over VCU Health's cleaning contract; says it intends to hire the full frontline team.
VCU Health
VCU Health
Academic health system
Selected HHS to replace Crothall; transition set for Nov. 1

Richmond-based academic health system that owns Virginia Commonwealth University's medical facilities and selected HHS as its new cleaning contractor.
SEIU Local 32BJ
SEIU Local 32BJ
Labor union
Represented about 400 Crothall housekeeping and maintenance workers at VCU Health; HHS recognition unresolved

Service Employees International Union Local 32BJ represents Crothall's housekeeping and maintenance workers at VCU Health.
Virginia Works (Virginia Employment Commission)
Virginia Works (Virginia Employment Commission)
State agency
Maintains WARN Act notices; received Crothall's August 28 filing

Virginia's state workforce agency that publishes WARN Act notices and tracks mass layoffs.

Timeline

March 2025 November 2026

6 events Latest: November 1st, 2026 · 1 week ago
Tap a bar to jump to that date

  1. HHS contract start date

    Latest Contract Start

    New contractor was scheduled to take over VCU Health environmental services.

  2. Crothall layoffs scheduled for Oct. 31

    Scheduled Event

    All 545 positions were scheduled to end as the contract expired.

  3. Crothall says layoffs expected to be permanent

    Statement

    HR business partner John Lytch told Virginia the company expected the layoffs to be permanent, though most workers could continue with the successor contractor.

  4. VCU Health names HHS as successor contractor

    Statement

    Hospital said HHS Environmental Services would take over cleaning contract November 1.

  5. Crothall files WARN notice for 545 layoffs

    Filing

    Crothall notifies Virginia of permanent closure at VCU Health site, effective October 31.

  6. SEIU contract ratified with pay raises

    Labor Agreement

    Housekeeping and maintenance workers ratify three-year contract with $3.30/hour raises.

Scenarios

1

HHS hires most workers, SEIU keeps representation

Likely Resolves by Q1 2027

Discussed by: HHS public statements, Virginia Business reporting

HHS follows through on its pledge to hire the full frontline team. Because it hires a majority of Crothall's workforce, the NLRB's successorship doctrine obligates HHS to recognize SEIU and bargain in good faith. A new contract is negotiated, potentially with adjusted pay and benefits.

2

NLRB fight over union recognition

Possible Resolves by Q2 2027

Discussed by: SEIU Local 32BJ, NLRB successorship precedent

HHS hires most Crothall workers but declines to recognize SEIU, arguing the workforce composition changed enough to break continuity. SEIU files an unfair labor practice charge with the NLRB regional office. A regional director must rule on whether HHS is a successor employer obligated to bargain.

Historical Context

2 moments from history that rhyme with this story — and how they unfolded.

1972

NLRB v. Burns International Security Services (1972)

The Supreme Court ruled that a new contractor that hires a majority of its predecessor's employees must recognize and bargain with the incumbent union. But the successor is not automatically bound by the predecessor's collective bargaining agreement.

Then

Established the successorship doctrine: a new employer who hires a majority workforce inherits the duty to bargain with the existing union.

Now

The doctrine has governed contractor transitions for over 50 years, giving unions a foothold when contracts change hands but not guaranteeing prior terms.

Why this matters now

If HHS hires most of Crothall's 545 workers, this doctrine requires HHS to recognize SEIU Local 32BJ and negotiate a new contract.

1974

Howard Johnson Co. v. Hotel & Restaurant Employees (1974)

The Supreme Court limited successorship obligations, ruling that a new employer cannot be forced to arbitrate under the predecessor's union contract and has no duty to hire the predecessor's employees.

Then

Clarified that successors are only obligated to bargain if they actually hire a majority of the predecessor's workforce.

Now

Gave contractors flexibility to staff differently, but created the risk that workers lose previous contract gains when employers change.

Why this matters now

HHS is not required to hire any Crothall workers and is not bound by the March 2025 SEIU contract. This case defines the limits of what workers can demand.

Sources

(5)
Virginia Works (Virginia Employment Commission) Virginia Business CBS 6 (WTVR) Crothall Healthcare WRIC ABC 8News